I use the term “elusive” because I had questions about James Reed’s service in Quebec (May and June of 1776) that I was unable to answer as I wrote about him in The War has Begun. The biographical sketches I found only agreed agreed on one fact: that he was rendered blind due to a “malignant” illness he acquired at Crown Point in early July of 1776, during the Continental Army’s retreat from Quebec.
One account, provided by Amos Blake in 1888, indicates Reed negotiated with Native Americans in the absence of Benedict Arnold, which would presumably have been in Quebec as that was the only time Reed and Arnold were in close proximity. I could find no evidence to support this claim. Blake mentions a letter to Congress, which may no longer exist. I searched through the Library of Congress’s holdings and the New Hampshire Provincial Congress’s records and found nothing from Reed.
Add to this, the fact that Arnold was in command of Montreal, where I am now certain Reed did not go (though his regiment did). However, Arnold did negotiate with Native Americans prior to Reed’s arrival in Quebec.
With regard to Amos Blake, he was a resident of Fitzwilliam, NH, the town Reed marched from in response to the alarm of April 19, 1775. Blake was a state senator, and apparently had an interest in history and Fitzwilliam’s most famous Revolutionary War soldier, James Reed.
For context, I should include that James Reed’s character is consistently referred to in the highest regard. Thus, I am merely at a loss for details of his service from late May to July of 1776, when his 3rd New Hampshire Regiment was assigned to the Northern Department, which meant being sent under Brigadier General John Sullivan to support the army already in Quebec.
Between Dr. Lewis Beebe’s journal and correspondence between Sullivan and Arnold (in George Washington’s papers at the Library of Congress), I was able to establish where Reed was, and the following list is what I do feel confident about:
- June 3, 1776: Journal of Dr. Lewis Beebe notes that Sullivan’s Brigade, which includes Reed’s Regiment marched for Fort St. Johns to Fort Chambly.
- June 5, Dr. Beebe’s journal entry, tells of Colonel Reed having small pox very lightly. Noting Beebe was at St. Johns, and he described Reed as being on the other side of the river, establishing he was not at Chambly with his regiment. Note that Reed’s second in command, LTC Israel Gilman, had gone ahead of the regiment and was already at Chambly on May 30th to participate in a council of war.
- June 8, General Sullivan writes to General Washington, where he includes that Reed’s Regiment only had forty fit men (owing to sickness). [I suspect this was exaggerated]
- June 12, Alexander’s Scammell’s report on the troops in Canada (in Washington’s papers) shows about two thirds of Reed’s regiment is at Montreal. Note that Scammell prepared the report while in Montreal, and therefore had first-hand knowledge.
- June 12, Dr. Beebe’s journal entry: “By invitation crossed the river and dined with
Colo. Reed, Mr. Barnum & a number of other Gent’n Had a most elegant table in the wilderness. It is pleasant and agreeable in this Strange land, now and then to see old friends, and be a little sociable in retirement.” This places Reed at St. Johns, and not in Montreal. This also implies Reed was not terribly afflicted with the Small Pox. [Also, in reading Beebe’s journal, I note he was not given to sarcasm or overstatement]
- June 13, Reed’s Regiment is noted as being at Montreal by the account in the 2nd New Jersey regiment’s orderly book.
- June 13, Benedict Arnold writes from Chambly, to General Sullivan. Arnold indicates he was in St. Johns on the 12th, and notes the place was in “the greatest confusion”. No mention of negotiations with native Americans.
Given the above, Blake’s claim seems unlikely. One bit of good fortune, however, was while researching this blog, I found the transcript of James Garfield’s 1899 talk on James Reed, which contained a great deal of information about Reed’s service during the Seven Years War. However, his time in Quebec was summed up with this rather generic statement, “Col. Reed was active and efficient in conducting the retreat from that point to Ticonderoga, where they arrived on the first of July.”
Last, if you know of the source Blake used, or have additional information about General James Reed’s time in Quebec, please leave a comment telling me about it.
Beebe, Lewis, 1935 “Journal of a Physician on the Expedition Against Canada in 1776” The Pennsylvania Magazine Vol LIX, Number Four.
Blake, Amos J. 1888. “GEN. JAMES REED. Sketch of his Life and Character”, Proceedings of the New Hampshire Historical Society. Vol. 1 Part 4 1884-1888. pp. 109-115. P113: On one occasion, in the absence of Arnold, he received and held a talk with the chiefs of some Indian tribes. It was managed with address, and successfully concluded by Colonel Reed ; and the pledges of their friendly disposition were transmitted by him to the president of congress. No record of this is indicated in either the Continental Congress or the New Hampshire Congress.
Fitzpatrick, John C. “The Writings of George Washington from the Original Manuscript Sources, 1745-1799” in “The George Washington Papers at the Library of Congress, 1741-1799” accessed throughout 2015 and 2016. Scammell’s report and Sullivan’s & Arnold’s correspondence are in this collection.
Garfield, James F.D. 1899 (read) 1908 (published) “General James Reed” Proceedings of the Fitchburg Historical Society and Papers Relating to the History of the Town read by some members. Vol IV pp. 113-124.
Salsig, Doyen. 1980. “Parole: Quebec; Countersign: Ticonderoga; Second New Jersey Regimental Orderly Book 1776” Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, Toronto
5 thoughts on “On the Elusive History of Brigadier General James Reed”
Writing an article on James Reed for Revolutionary War Journal. I found your article interesting and useful. I will cite your article in resources. Thank You. Harry Schenawolf
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, and I am looking forward to your article. At one point eight or ten years ago, I was in touch with one of the historians at the Boston National Historical Park based on my maps of the battle and Boston in 1775. It came up that he was a descendent of Reed’s, so he had paid particular attention to the position of Reed’s men in the maps. Pro Patria – CF
Reed’s Regiment is said to have gone to Canada via New York City. Do you have any details on when Reed was in NYC? Somehow, one of his men ended up there as a British prisoner in December 1776. I’m trying to determine if he was left behind (sick?) when the regiment passed through or whether he was captured later and transferred to New York by the British.
I found quite a few details of the regiment in New York City in 1776. Two items in particular, which were first, Lt. Grover’s courts martial – of which my ancestor was a witness in the trial, and second that Reed was entrusted to carry the payroll northward to General Schuyler. They were not in New York very long, but certainly long enough for some men to have taken sick and get left behind. There would not have been a way for those men to catch up as once Reed’s men reached Fort Edward, they moved overland to the southern tip of Lake George and then on to Fort Ticonderoga and then to Canada via Lake Champlain. My first book, “The War has Begun” details all of this, including citations for each of the documented events that occurred on that journey, of which there were more than a dozen.
Thanks for your prompt reply! I just happened upon your site this morning. Your Breed’s Hill pdf was useful as well. I’ll order a copy of the book.
LikeLiked by 1 person